gs2
150 Words10 Marks
Q.From the resolution of contentious issues regarding distribution of legislative powers by the courts, 'Principle of Federal Supremacy' and 'Harmonious Construction' have emerged. Explain.
UPSC Mains 2019•Polity
Model Answer
View this Question In PYQ RealmSyllabus Point
- Functions and Responsibilities of the Union and the States, Issues and Challenges Pertaining to the Federal Structure, Devolution of Powers and Finances up to Local Levels and Challenges Therein.
Approach
- Introduction (Definition) (30-40 words): Introduce the concept of Indian federalism and the distribution of legislative powers between the Union and States.
- Body (Explanation) (80-90 words):
- Explain the Principle of Harmonious Construction with relevant case law.
- Explain the Principle of Federal Supremacy.
- Discuss how these principles resolve legislative conflicts.
- Conclusion (20 words): Summarize how these judicial doctrines maintain balance in India's cooperative federalism.
Introduction
The distribution of legislative powers between the Centre and States in India has frequently led to disputes. To resolve these conflicts, the judiciary has developed key interpretative doctrines: the "Principle of Federal Supremacy" and the "Doctrine of Harmonious Construction".
Body
1. Principle of Harmonious Construction
- Definition: When a conflict arises between entries in the Union List and the State List, the court avoids declaring a law invalid. Instead, it interprets the provisions such that both can coexist constructively.
- Premise: Every statute has a distinct legislative intent and must be read as a whole. The courts attempt to reconcile inconsistencies in language to give the widest possible effect to both entries.
- Example: In Shri Krishna Rangnath Mudholkar v. Gujarat University (1963), the Supreme Court resolved a conflict regarding the medium of instruction. It allowed the State to legislate on education as long as it did not directly conflict with the Union's power to maintain standards in higher education.
2. Principle of Federal Supremacy
- Definition: If a direct, irreconcilable conflict arises between an entry in List I (Union List) and List II (State List), the Union law prevails. This establishes the predominant legislative authority of the Federation.
- Application: When a subject falls simultaneously under both lists, the Centre's legislative power dominates. The State and Concurrent lists are subordinate to the Union List.
- Judicial Restraint: The Supreme Court applies federal supremacy only as a last resort, after all attempts to harmoniously construct or reconcile the statutes have failed.
Conclusion
In an era of cooperative and competitive federalism, these judicial doctrines ensure that Centre-State legislative conflicts are minimized, fostering a uniform yet flexible legislative framework across key national areas.
Previous Questionthere is a growing divergence in the relationship between poverty and hunger in India. The shrinking of social expenditure by the government is forcing the poor to spend more on non-food essential items squeezing their food budget. Elucidate
Next QuestionThe long-sustained image of India as a leader of the oppressed and marginalised nations has disappeared on account of its new found role in the emerging global order.’ Elaborate.